The Battle of the Gods and Giants (ebook)

Argumento de The Battle of the Gods and Giants (ebook)

By the mid-1600s, the commonsense, manifest picture of the world associated with Aristotle had been undermined by skeptical arguments on the one hand and by the rise of the New Science on the other. What would be the scientific image to succeed the Aristotelian model? Thomas Lennon argues here that the contest between the supporters of Descartes and the supporters of Gassendi to decide this issue was the most important philosophical debate of the latter half of the seventeenth century. Descartes and Gassendi inspired their followers with radically opposed perspectives on space, the objects in it, and how these objects are known. Lennon maintains that differing concepts on these matters implied significant moral and political differences: the Descartes/Gassendi conflict was typical of Plato's perennial battle of the gods (friends of forms) and giants (materialists), and the crux of that enduring philosophical struggle is the exercise of moral and political authority.

Lennon demonstrates, in addition, that John Locke should be read as having taken up Gassendi's cause against Descartes. In Lennon's reinterpretation of the history of philosophy between the death dates of Gassendi and Malebranche, Locke's acknowledged opposition to Descartes on some issues is applied to the most important questions of Locke exegesis.

Originally published in 1993.

The Princeton Legacy Library uses the latest print-on-demand technology to again make available previously out-of-print books from the distinguished backlist of Princeton University Press. These paperback editions preserve the original texts of these important books while presenting them in durable paperback editions. The goal of the Princeton Legacy Library is to vastly increase access to the rich scholarly heritage found in the thousands of books published by Princeton University Press since its founding in 1905.0Preface Note on Documentation I The Philosophical Terrain 3 1 The Gassendist Failure 3 2 The Gassendist Success 26 3 The Interminable Battle 34 4 Other Wars 52 II The Giants of the Seventeenth Century 63 5 Dramatis Personae 63 6 Mind versus Flesh 106 7 Gassendist Theories of Space: Apotheosis and Annihilation 117 8 Physical and Metaphysical Atomism 137 III Locke: Gassendist Anti-Cartesian 149 9 Locke and Gassendi 149 10 Locke and Descartes 163 11 Enthusiasm 169 IV The Gods of the Seventeenth Century 191 12 Descartes's Idealism 191 13 Malebranche's Realism 210 14 Malebranche's Idealism 229 V Ideas and Representation 240 15 Two Patterns of Ideas 240 16 Arguments for Representationalism 248 17 Two Versions of the Causal Argument 255 VI The Untouchable and the Uncuttable 274 18 Space and Solidity 276 19 Simple and Complex Ideas 288 20 Primary and Secondary Qualities 298 21 Powers 304 22 Matter and Creation 309 23 The Bestial Soul 314 VII Innateness, Abstraction, and Essences 334 24 Innateness 334 25 Essences and Abstraction 340 26 The Polemic with Stillingfleet 354 VIII Philosophy and the Historiography of Philosophy 367 27 Dissimulation and Meaning 368 28 What Locke Said 374 29 Two Camps of Historians 378 30 History and Interpretation 383 Works Cited 393 Index 411